"Why don't you therapists go on strike for better payment from insurance companies?"Rideshare drivers – that is gig-economy drivers for companies like Uber and Lyft – are in exactly the same situation in their relationship to rideshare platforms as psychotherapists are in relationship to insurance companies: they are considered independent contractors – businesses – and as such it would be a violation of antitrust law for them to collectively bargain, both federal antitrust law and our local Massachusetts antitrust law.
Ah, because that would be massively illegal.
Therapists, from time to time, do go on strike. In Washington state in 2014, therapists employed by Behavioral Health Resource went on strike. In California in 2013, mental health care workers at Telecare La Casa Mental Health Rehabilitation Center went on strike. And in California in 2014, therapists employed by Kaiser Permanente's Oakland Medical Center went on strike.
You know what the therapists had in common in each of cases? They were employees striking against their employers.
Remember what I said about the difference in legal protections between employers and independent contractors? One of those legal protections for employees, hard won, was the right of organizing and collective bargaining. Strikes are mostly legal, for employees.
But an independent contractor isn't an employee. They're a business, which is selling a service to another business. And when businesses band together to force a customer – in this case insurers – to pay more for something? That's called price fixing and is a flagrant, unambiguous violation of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act of 1890.
It is illegal for therapists working as contractors or in private practice to organize any sort of strike or boycott against the insurance companies that pay so little. [PDF]
Fox News senior medical analyst Dr. Marc Siegel on who is most at risk for whooping cough and what is contributing to the rise in cases....Wut.
ANCHOR: The CDC reporting a more than 340% rise in whooping cough from last year, with 10 states reporting the highest rates in the country, here to discuss what's causing this uptick on this Medical Monday, Fox News senior medical analyst, Dr. Marc Siegel. Dr Siegel, that seems concerning! What's causing this?WUT.
DR SIEGEL: Well, this is something really to watch out for, because a third of all children under the age of one who get this, Kayleigh, wind up hospitalized.
ANCHOR: Wow.
DR SIEGEL: It's burgeoning around the world. That's number one. There's over 24 million cases in the world. Most of it in underdeveloped areas that don't have the really excellent vaccine for this, that I'll talk about in a minute: that's number one.
Number two, coming out of the pandemic[*], kids haven't seen this before[**], so they're exposed to it and they get sick from it.
Number three, adults harbor this, and we don't even know we have it. Cause it seems like a virus.[***] It's just, for us, a regular cough, a little fever, you think it's a virus[***]. It's not productive so you don't think of a bacteria. [****] This is a bacteria. [****] And we can treat it with azithromycin, by the way, with Zithromax — if we know it's a bacteria. But little kids get it, and their airways aren't developed, and you hear thatwhoop. It's a whistle. It sounds like a whistle. [...]
The number one reason, in my opinion, that we can fight this is that our vaccination rate is down, and it's an excellent vaccine, completely safe, it's mandatory in all fifty states, but a lot of exceptions are being given — also the migrant issue[*****] — so it's down to around 90% now, which leads to a surge of this. And that can endanger very, very young children. I'm really worried about that increase to 17,000 cases. And — Kayleigh! — That's the ones we know about!
ANCHOR: Yeah!
DR SIEGEL: There's thousands and thousands more we don't know about.
ANCHOR: Dr. Siegel, I'm concerned! I read 160,000 children under five die globally each year because of whooping cough. And, you know, I have a 4-year-old, I have a 1-year-old. What do we look for? You said that whooping sound, but my kids come home sick from school every week it seems.[******]
DR SIEGEL: Well the 1-year-old is the one I would keep the most eye on because [... Discussion of pertussis symptomology elided for length...]
ANCHOR: And there's that Tdap vaccination: how long does that last, so parents know?
DR SIEGEL: So it's DTaP for kids, up to the age of seven — DTaP. And Tdap for kids over the age of seven. And I think it lasts for 3 to 5 years*******, so if you get vaccinated before kindergarten, you're in good shape. They give three or four shots early in life and I recommend, strongly, that everybody take this, because really young children are at risk, under the age one most at risk.